Xentim Book a demo
Case study

Four fire scenarios in a real underground garage: what a crowd engine shows

A car catches fire next to the stairwell of an underground garage. Forty seconds later smoke cuts the stairwell off, and 66 people who were walking towards it have to turn round and cross the whole garage to the vehicle ramp. For almost half a minute nobody gets out. We ran this and three other scenarios on a 3D scan of a real garage, seen through the cameras that hang there today.

Piotr BuczkowskiPiotr Buczkowskifounder of Xentim·
Scenario G2 through the six CCTV cameras found on the scan: the building and the camera views are real, the people are simulated. Colour shows how crowded each person is. Licence plates are masked.

Why we are building our own crowd engine

A classic evacuation study ends as a floor plot and a table of times. It answers where people get stuck. It does not show what that looks like in a particular building, through its cameras, for the people who have to decide what to change.

We started with one-off simulations: a concert field, this garage, a series of panic cases. Every new venue meant new work, and two scenarios built by hand could quietly follow slightly different rules. So we pulled everything into one engine. A scenario goes in, a result comes out, and the same result can be shown on a floor plan, in 3D or on a scan of a real building.

The garage

The garage is a real underground car park, scanned with a handheld 3D scanner. From the scan we took the floor people can walk on (596 m² between cars, pillars and walls), the two exits (a stairwell and the vehicle ramp) and the positions of six CCTV cameras, with the direction each one looks. Every scenario below uses the evacuation model, the one checked against the IMO tests.

Four scenarios

ScenarioPeopleWhat happens90% outLast person outStairwell / ramp
G1 Alarm, no fire150both exits stay open71 s80 s118 / 32
G2 Car fire by the stairwell150smoke closes the stairwell at 40 s141 s171 s51 / 99
G3 Electric car fire by the ramp150smoke closes the ramp at 30 s74 s83 s129 / 21
G4 Peak hour300smoke closes the stairwell at 40 s221 s267 s50 / 250
All four scenarios on the same clock, three times real speed. Green: free walking. Amber and red: crowded. Star: the burning car. An exit turns red when smoke closes it.
Four garage scenarios side by side, 30 seconds after the alarmFour garage scenarios side by side, 60 seconds after the alarmFour garage scenarios side by side, 120 seconds after the alarm
The same moment in all four scenarios. Switch between 30, 60 and 120 seconds after the alarm. Click the picture to enlarge it.

What the numbers say

Chart of the share of people out over time for the four garage scenarios
Share of people out over time. The flat parts are the moments when nobody reaches an exit: people who lost the stairwell are still crossing the garage.

The stairwell carries this garage. With both exits open, 118 of 150 people leave by the stairs. When smoke closes them, the time until 90% are out doubles, from 71 to 141 seconds.

Losing the ramp barely matters. When the electric car by the ramp fills it with smoke, most people were heading for the stairs anyway. The time to 90% grows by three seconds. A fire safety plan that treats both exits as equal misses this difference.

Half a minute with nobody getting out. In G2 the curve goes flat after the stairwell closes. The people who were queueing there walk back across the garage, and for almost 30 seconds nobody reaches an exit.

At peak hour the queue moves inside. With 300 people the jam does not form at the ramp. It forms where the aisle narrows beside a pillar on the way to the ramp, with up to 5.4 people per square metre. That is a spot a camera should watch and a place where a parked car or a pallet would make things worse.

These results compare variants of one building. They are not a fire safety assessment, they do not model smoke physics (smoke here only closes an exit) and they do not replace the fire engineer's report. Every video and chart says so.

The same engine on a festival field

The panic model handles what a garage evacuation does not: a crowd pushing. On a concert field with 2,640 people, a surge towards the stage left 11% of the people in the front area on the ground. Splitting the front area into pens with a second barrier line cut that to 6.5% in the same surge. These numbers are for comparing two layouts, not for predicting injuries.

The same surge towards the stage, without pens (left) and with the front area split into pens (right). Colour shows contact pressure on the body; a white cross marks a person who fell.

What comes next

Next is a panel inside Unreal Engine: drag crowd zones, exits, barriers and fires onto a scan, press Simulate, keep each run as a version and play two versions side by side. After that, different kinds of people (children, older people, wheelchair users), groups that stay together, and several runs per variant so the answer is a range instead of one number.

For a garage manager the useful question is simple: which exit really carries your building, and what happens when that one is gone? Which one would it be in yours?

Questions and answers

Is a crowd simulation a fire safety assessment?

No. It shows how people move in a given layout and lets you compare variants: an exit closed, more people, a different fire location. The formal assessment stays with a fire safety engineer. Our videos and reports carry the note “simulation for demonstration, not a safety assessment”.

What do you need from the site?

A 3D scan of the building or a floor plan with exits. With a scan we also place virtual cameras where the real CCTV cameras hang, so each scenario can be watched through them.

How was the crowd model checked?

The evacuation model passes 10 of the 12 verification tests in IMO MSC.1/Circ.1533. It fails the two tests with a very dense crowd at a narrow door, where it locks up. For crowds pushing against each other we use a separate panic model, which passes the counterflow test.

How long does one scenario take to compute?

In this garage, 150 people take 25 to 60 seconds and 300 people about three and a half minutes. A 2,600 person panic scenario on a festival field takes about four minutes.

All numbers come from our own simulation runs on 17 November 2026. The garage is shown with the owner's permission; licence plates are masked. Sources: IMO MSC.1/Circ.1533, Revised guidelines on evacuation analysis for new and existing passenger ships. Helbing D., Farkas I., Vicsek T., Simulating dynamical features of escape panic, Nature 407, 2000.

Read also
Case study: from a five-minute room scan to a digital twin you can rearrangeCase study: what one camera told us about how people use a courtyardThe case was dropped because no one had time to watch the footageNight shift, two people, forty camerasA sofa bed by the bins and four days of footageThe trail camera took the photo. Who will look at it?A car stalls on the tracks. The signaller knows within secondsThe security queue builds at 5:40, and only two lanes are openHow many spaces are free? The camera already knows